Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
In my previous profession I've seen used, and tried myself, to offer the most heinous offering available. One guy kept faking seizures so medics said Out loud WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO INJECT HIS NECK! Guy jumped up screaming NOT IN MY NECK! NOT IN MY NECK! My recommendation is this.... stop running to their aid. Tell them since they cant be left alone they are going to a nursing home as a last resort. They SHOULD straighten up for awhile. Like children, they will regress so every couple of weeks have a new nursing home brochure laying around. Try it...
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
xhausted1 May 2020
Those tactics are effective...I’ve used versions of them myself...and they do regress. They have mastered sucking the joy out of life and really don’t make you even want to be around them, let alone do anything to make their lives more pleasant.
(9)
Report
Oh my Dad is an expert at it....

Last time he had a cold. Called the GP out 3 times. Called an ambulance a few times. All said "no you're fine". He was convinced he should be in hospital because he was "so ill"

Lo and behold, next day hes fallen, banged his head and ended up in hospital. Got what he wanted of course. Even the hospital admitted the wound was very suspect - it looks like he basically opened the cupboard door in the kitchen and scraped his head along the bottom a bit. His story was he'd forgotten he'd left it open and walked into it.

Total fabrication. Hes done this 2-3 times now. Last time I didnt even rush to the hospital to see him.

Trouble is I'm in the UK so all healthcare is free so no issues there. Also, I guess the health professionals err on the side of caution and take him in regardless and he knows this.

In the past, he has been banned from calling out the GP and the ambulance service did take 6 hours to come last time. They've got his card marked I think.

Paramedics I think are pretty close to 100% sure its a fake when they refuse to take him to hospital.

I've said this a number of times - hes cried wolf so many times I'll probably find him dead in his chair one day and I'll be like "Oops he was ill this time". I've made my peace with that - its his fault. I can't spend my life running back and fore 20 miles each time 1000 times just in case its not fake this one time.....
Helpful Answer (12)
Report
Atmywitsend40 May 2020
I hate that people on the forum think that we are callous because we refuse to have the life zapped out of us by family that feel like they can have control of us until the choose to stop whenever that is. My granny is going to be 90 in Aug. Had always worked tirelessly to help her even when she didn't help me and kicked me out of the house because I wouldn't tell her my plans for the future. Worked 10 hours to pick her up across town fill out a 12 page application to have her tell me once we left that she didn't wanna take the apt because it was old people there and she doesn't think that the leasing lady wanted her to have the apt. This happened maybe 3 times before I am like I am not doing this with you. A couple of years later I move now she wants to get info about MY apts that is about 45 mins from her. That fizzles out. Got to the point where she was barely calling but going to all her religious services about 4 times a week . let her know that this was not something that I was going to doing running behind her to see about her well being. I am here to see about your well being not be a slave. She falls does not tell me for 2 weeks. Yes I went off because she knew what she was doing. About a month later she falls then calls me when heading to the hospital. Get to the room at the hospital the first thing out her mouth was where was her Chickfila. She get up to go to the bathroom by then the nurse in there. I have medical power of attorney the nurse lets me know that her pressure is sky high and that she is a fall risk. She hid her arm from me so I couldn't see her wrist band. It was the most hilarious thing ever to her that she had gotten over and went to the bathroom by herself. At that moment I realized that this is not something that I will be doing anymore because it is not good for my well being as a person. I check on her 3 times a week and have groceries delivered to her when needed. I refuse to spend my life stressed out because you refuse to let go of control and I have a life now. I definitely understand when you say that you are at peace with it because I did the same thing. I don't talk about it with people about it because you get the " you know growing old is hard" bs or Well it's your granny you only have one. You don't have to deal with her everyday so put a sock in it lol. I don't have to deal with abuse.
(4)
Report
I think in some of the heads of our elders it's "desperate times call for desperate measures" and a fall fits that.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Wow, the stories of "fake falling" are fascinating... I would never have guessed. I keep learning new things on this forum daily.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

I feel this, I really do. Father in law has had some legitimate falls. But he has also had what we call "convenient" falls when his narcissistic supply is not flowing the way he likes it. The difference? When he really falls, there is some kind of injury, no matter how small. And he weighs 300+ pounds, so when he falls, you can hear it anywhere in the house and even someplaces just outside of the house.When it is more staged? He's basically on the floor in the most comfortable position possible, able to access phone and tv remote but not push the button on the lanyard somehow. And it is very quiet.
The last time he fell, sister in law and her husband, who live with him, had come to visit us. As FIL is unable to access our home because of several stairs, and he is capable of staying home for several hours alone, he was home. SIL/BIL and our family had just finished dinner and were getting ready for dessert when my husband's phone rang. He started off normal conversation for several minutes and then told him what happened. So he fell, in the floor, his phone beside of him and he told DH he was on his back. We stayed on the phone with him the entire time it took for SIL/BIL to get back to him. He had somehow flipped over while on the phone with DH (another clue, as he is like a turtle when he is on his back, he cannot roll over) and is now on his stomach, head near the bed. There was no sound of huffing or puffing or movement, which is also his signature especially on the phone because it brings the question "are you ok" repeatedly.
While on the phone, since this was not the first time and we saw the opportunity since he said his knee hurt, we told him when they got there an ambulance would be called and he would be transported because he really seemed to need evaluation. 2 times in the previous several weeks he had experienced "soft falls" and since he is two-person assist the fire department always has to come. So this time they transported and he went to rehab after the hospital. When COVID-19 illicited the stay at home order in our state I had a long talk with father in law (not the first time I've had similar talks with him when his convenient falls would not bring him what he was looking for) that he didn't want to have to call an ambulance for anything short of a real emergency right now because they wouldn't likely transport to the hospital (he LOVES it there) and if they did we would not be allowed to visit for the duration. Not a single fall. I know that he could legitimately fall. But we can see the signs when he is ramping up for a health crisis of his own making and in general it helps if we head him off. Another time we did this was when my mother and my brother in laws mother were both having surgery around the same time and our attention was naturally diverted. I told him if he had anything short of a real emergency he was going to be on his own. As soon and I do mean the day that my mother and BILs mother were ok to be on their own guess who called to say he was in the ER....for a cold ( they sent him home). So we know he has control over a number of these events. We take them all seriously because anyone of them could be. But we can definitely tell the difference now.
TL:DR story- yes we believe father in law stages "safe" falls when he isn't getting enough attention because it gains everyone including first responders on a non-emergency call.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

I purchased a "help I've fallen" button for my parents when they still lived in their home, and they had those buttons on for the rest of their lives. There is one that automatically calls for help when it senses a sudden drop/fall. That way, if she passes out and falls, or trips and falls, or just plain falls, help will be called immediately. Another option is to hire a companion to stay with her when you need to leave. The "nanny cam" is also a really good idea.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I purchased a "help I've fallen" button for my parents when they still lived in their home, and they had those buttons on for the rest of their lives. There is one that automatically calls for help when it senses a sudden drop/fall. That way, if she passes out and falls, or trips and falls, or just plain falls, help will be called immediately. Another option is to hire a companion to stay with her when you need to leave.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I think some people are so afraid they will be forgotten about that they will constantly make sure something is "wrong" so that they stay in the forefront of everyone's minds. A "fall" would certainly fit into this category and get them lots of attention.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I don’t have direct experience but I know a woman with a mother who did those kinds of things in order to control or induce guilt. She (Daughter) figured it out by installing cameras in the house. What you do about the behavior is another question. Does you mom have a controlling manner?
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
gemswinner12 May 2020
Good advice! Get a motion-activated camera in place ( you can get the camera in a picture frame or teddy bear...not very expensive on amazon), then announce loudly that you’re leaving her alone . Make sure the camera’s in place, and go out to eat nearby ( if your restaurants are opening up soon...or a trip to the grocery store would also work).
The only downside to checking out this hunch would be if she manages to actually hurt herself while acting ( some famous actors have been hurt while working). Seriously though, it’s a good idea whether she’s faking or not; you could gain peace of mind while out on some well-deserved breaks.
(5)
Report
I suspect my FIL once faked falling. He had one caregiver coming Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays for a few hours in the morning. The fall happened in the morning on one of her days off. He lives in indy living where there's a big red button to call for help in *every* single room with *two* in the bathroom (one next to the toilet and one in the shower). He fell in the bathroom and instead of pushing the button next to the toilet, he called my husband.

My husband dropped everything he was doing, drove over there to find his dad on the carpet outside the bathroom. He assists him up and asks what happened. No real explanation besides "I fell while peeing" and no injuries not even red knee caps. His pants were all zipped up and the toilet was flushed, odd considering he said he fell while peeing!

Anyway, that was the first and last time my husband went to pick his father up off the floor. He told him to use the red button because that's what he pays all that money for at indy living. After that, the caregiver started coming 5 days a week.

Both my husband and I believe he fake "fell" to get attention. He now has 2 shifts of caregivers 7 days a week despite not actually needing that much help. I think he's afraid to be alone. Yet he did not avail himself of most of the activities at indy living pre-pandemic. His money is running out.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
xhausted1 May 2020
I think the days get long when you’re not occupied. Their behavior should be a lesson to all of us who are more technologically inclined...we need to have “jobs” we can do from home...tutoring/teaching English on line, whatever. Life becomes a death sentence...literally...when the plans for the day are limited to eating and eliminating what you’ve eaten.
(2)
Report
My mother faked falling many times until she was able to qualify for a hip replacement. She also fell 'legitimately' meaning she'd have some pretty horrific bruises to show for it.

She also does this thing where she'll tell you she's been vomiting non-stop for hours, and you'll find her with a small basin in her lap---BUT no evidence of any vomit--place doesn't smell of it, the basin is dry, I actually took it from her hands once and it wasn't just dry, it was DUSTY.

She just craves attention, always has. Sadly, even though we have a huge family, she sees very few of us. She won't call just to chat--even tho any of us would enjoy a pleasant conversation. She cannot use her cell phone and YB won't reconnect her old landline. She doesn't want her 'problems' solved--she wants to complain.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
lkdrymom May 2020
That was my father. He craves attention and wants someone to 'fuss' over him. Anyone who knows me knows I am incapable of 'fussing'. Every time he called his first words were "I've got a problem...". The crazy thing was he seemed miffed when I solved his problems...he didn't want the problem 'fixed', he just wanted me there 'working on it'. Fixing it means there is nothing to fuss and dither over. I would not put a fake fall past him. So many phone calls "I think I am DYING!!!!" and there would be nothing wrong with him.
(9)
Report
See 3 more replies
Yes, my FIL faked falling, and other serious health problems, so that he could get attention. He also fell in reality. So you never knew unless you saw him. He was brazen about it, often just lying down on the ground and pretending to be comatose, even when other people were watching him, e.g. knowing he hadn't fallen, that he had just gotten himself down on the ground.

So, if your instincts are telling you that she faked it, she might have. On the other hand, as I said, she might just have been truly disoriented and scared from being alone, and felt faint, and took a tumble. Fear is a very real problem for elders. Their fear seems to be linked to them doing many strange things they wouldn't have in the past, and also can cause them to have panic attacks.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Hi Christine-
Ive been here on AC for about 5 years. It always amazes me that no matter how bizarre the situation may be - someone here has also experienced it. But, yours is the first other Falling on Purpose post I’ve seen. Yes, my mother “fell” on purpose. Why?

Its a long, complicated story about a complicated woman but I’ll try to be brief.

After a three week say in rehab my mother was moved from a IL apartment into an AL apartment. In the first ten days my mom fell twice. The AL admin said her “needs were to high” and that I needed to move her out. They agreed to give me time to find a good NH as long as an outside, licensed paid caregiver was with her.

So, that’s what we did. The process took about two months - due to my brother but that’s another story. My mom loved having the caregiver- both for companionship and seeing to her every want and need. Mom would have been THRILLED to live like that for the rest of her life but her outliving her money to pay for it was a concern. At least, for me. Mom had given away a huge chunk of change to “charities” - but that’s another story - and Medicaid wouldn’t have been an option for years.

Anyhoo - eventually, off to the NH mom went. A VERY nice, newer, private, boutique NH I might add, that mom hated before she ever got there - but that’s another story. Mom HATED the NH and wanted her 24/7 servant...err... caregivers back. What’s a gal to do, right?

Mom figured that since falling was
what got her 86’d from AL - falling would get her kicked out of the NH as well. Did I mention moms dementia? But, that’s another story.

It didn’t take long for mom to get busted falling on purpose. The give away was the time she had taken a pillow and blanket to be more comfortable on the floor while she waited to be discovered by some poor CNA.

After some time AND a visit to a Geriatric Psychiatrist along with a medication overhaul - the falls stopped. There was also a “Fall Plan” implemented by the NH which was very restricted in terms of allowing my mom to be alone in her room - a plan mom HATED. But together, it all stopped the falls.

Many months later...
Mom would forget that she was - by this time - wheelchair bound and she would get up in an attempt to walk. Mom wouldn’t really fall - it was more of a slow sinking to her knees as she hung onto something. Unable to get herself back up - that’s how they would find her. They would walk into her room and my mother would immediately snap “I didn’t fall. I was praying” in fear the dreaded Fall Plan would be reimplement.

You gotta laugh sometimes. Laugh or cry... but that’s another story.

I wish you the best of luck!
Helpful Answer (15)
Report
NYDaughterInLaw May 2020
What a great answer, Rainmom! I always love reading your answers.
(5)
Report
See 2 more replies
What makes you think she faked it? Why would she? My MIL wound up on the floor plenty of times on the carpeting and was never injured, just lost her balance and was able to do a controlled fall. If your MIL is behaving oddly, she may be sliding into dementia, or could have a UTI, or she could have balance problems which is very common in the elderly.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter